Friday, December 10, 2010
To enjoy Indian classical music, you must criticise it without too many inhibitions. Prejudice is preferred
There are nice differences between the two traditions and the singers were able to emphasise the strengths of each. Meeta's melodious rendering of Bhopali was captivating but one could not help noticing that it was the melody of her voice that carried the raag. No fault of either Meeta or that of the raag. That is how it was. On the other hand, Sudha's rendering highlighted the austere mode of the Carnatic style, where the focus is on the sharp play on the notes. But soon the two singers seemed to have unconsciously been drawn in by what the other was doing. Meeta went into the structural detail of the raag and Sudha let loose the melody in Mohanam. But each did it without giving up on the basic strength of their respective styles -- melody (Meeta) and pure structure (Sudha).
The last 15 minutes were given to singing a composition from Sanskrit poet Jayadeva's Ashtapadi, perhaps the right choice to bring together the two traditions.
Had it been a Carnatic recital alone, we would have heard four to five kritis or compositions before settlig down to delineate a raaga. A classical musician, it is to be assumed, is not so much interested in singing a song as he or she is in exploring the raaga. Which is perhaps what the cognoscenti would like too. There is a lot enjoyment in that. But, the general audience would like to hear words being strung on the raaga so that they can enjoy the song and the music.
There is a problem that has to be faced up front. In the Carnatic tradition, the 'sahitya' or compositions are an integral part. The 'sahitya' in the Hindustani variant is slightly thin. Of course, there are the compositions of Kabir, Surdas, Meera. The only time a song can come in is through a 'thumri' or 'tappa'.
So, in the Meeta-Sudha concert, the song was missing. The raaga delneation which comes in the latter part of the concert has been brought forward. The adjustment is perfectly acceptable but the gap remains.
This was followed by another hour of a 'dhrupad' concert by Umakant and Ramakant Gundecha. They too devoted 45 to 50 minutes for an 'aalaap' in Raag Pooria, which took a little time to pick up momentum but it was quite pleasing. But the most attractive part of the Gundecha concert was again the song. In the last 10 minutes they sang, 'Shankara girijapati shankara ...jat mein ganga trilochana trishuldhari..namo kailashpati' in Raag Malkauns, which was wonderful. It was sheer magic with the inherent rhythm of the 'dhrupad' style giving it a vervy edge.
The brothers took some time to settle down, setting the tanpuras and then the pakhawaj. When an objection was raised as to why the instruments could not be tuned in before the concert starts, devotees sharply reminded that that is the way and that one should not dare object to these things.
Perhaps the brothers could have restricted the 'aalaap' to 20 minutes and given the rest of the time for the song which is the real winning card for any vocal concert. The Malkauns became doubly pleasurable because of the words -- it did not matter that this was a 'bhajan'.
Critics misread Alankrita Shrivastava's "Lipstick Under My Burkha" . It is not about feminism's liberation theology
I was reminded of Paul Haggis' 2004 film, "Crash" when I watched Alankrita Shrivastava's "Lipstick Under My Burkha&qu...
There is plenty to crib about Ashutosh Gowariker-directed Hrithik-Roshan-Pooja Hegde starrer Mohenjo-Daro with uninspiring music by the ove...
Udta Punjab, bad film because it is message-oriented, it is incoherent and loud, and the roles of Shahid Kapoor and Alia Bhatt were superfluousAbhishek Chaubey, the director of Udta Punjab , is part of the new school of film directors from Uttar Pradesh, which includes Tigmanshu Dh...
Eye in the Sky: A war movie with a difference which deals with the dilemmas of killing the enemy and saving the innocentsThis is a British production with a South African director, a top notch British actress Helen Mirren and a top notch British actor Alan Rick...